The
mission of the Ohio Fair Schools Campaign is
to organize and advocate for high quality public
education opportunities for all Ohio children wherever
they live, whatever their race and whatever
their family background.
To: LWVO
From: Joan Platz
Education Update for February 11, 2008
1) State of the State Address:
Governor Ted Strickland recalled the
courage, ingenuity, and fortitude of those who first settled Ohio in
his second "State of the State Address", presented to a joint session
of Ohio House and Senate on February 6, 2008. In his address the
Governor focused on the accomplishments of his administration in
2007, the challenges Ohio is facing, and proposed initiatives to
complete work on the energy bill, serve veterans, create jobs,
rebuild infrastructure, expand higher education opportunities, take
authority for primary and secondary education, and more. The details
of the proposed initiatives need to be worked out, but it is assumed
that changes in law will be necessary to implement several of the
proposed initiatives. Lawmakers could include these changes in
separate legislation or through a budget corrections bill and/or a
capital budget. The text of the State of the State speech is
available at http://governor.ohio.gov/Default.aspx?tabid=799. A
summary of some of the proposed initiatives follows:
*Create the Ohio Department of Veterans Affairs as a cabinet-level
agency to serve veterans more effectively.
*Propose a ballot initiative to support the "Building Ohio Jobs" program, a $1.7 billion jobs stimulus package.
*Include in the ten-year plan for the University System of Ohio a
guarantee that students can complete an associate's and bachelor's
degree within thirty miles of their homes.
*Create the "Seniors to Sophomores Program", which will enable a
twelfth grade student who meets the academic requirements a choice of
spending their senior year in their home high school, or spending it
on a University System of Ohio campus -- starting the upcoming school
year. Chancellor Fingerhut has been directed to develop this
initiative, which will be built on the existing Post Secondary
Enrollment Options Program. Participating seniors will graduate from
high school ready to start their sophomore year in college without
paying for tuition. Students will receive their high school diploma
and one full year of college credits at the same time. The credits
will transfer in full to public institutions, as well as many private
colleges. According to Governor Strickland, "Its goal is to raise
the aspirations of all students, to challenge students who might feel
disengaged from their high school studies, and to help students who
want to accelerate their college education. And, just think about the
effect on a family's budget when they save the cost of an entire year
of college tuition."
*Promote the following vision for our schools:
-Strengthen our commitment to public education.
-Link education directly to economic prosperity. World class schools
will produce a talented workforce, and a talented workforce will
attract and create jobs.
-Identify the great strengths of our schools such as fostering
creativity and innovation. "Our schools must teach students to think
past the limits of what's been done, and imagine what could be done."
-Support talented teachers who want to stay in the classroom.
Consult with our best teachers to show us what works best in the
classroom
-Strive to develop a specific, personalized education program that
identifies how each individual student learns and uses the teaching
methods appropriate to that student's needs and abilities.
-Use testing and assessment to guide personalized and individualized
education through a comprehensive and ongoing understanding of a
student's capabilities and weaknesses and growth in the educational
process.
*Create the position of director of the Department of Education,
appointed by the governor with the approval of the Senate. The
director would have oversight over all Department of Education
efforts.
"The existing structure, including the State Board of Education and
the State Superintendent of Schools, would remain in place in
advisory and additional roles as determined by the director."
"This change in organizational structure will ensure, like higher
education, that there is a direct line of responsibility and
accountability in K through 12 education."
"It will ensure that our elected and appointed leaders are working
together to strengthen education in Ohio."
"Education is the central issue I face as governor. I am determined
to bring real change and real results. But I am also determined to
find the best answers. We are creating a blueprint for the future of
our schools and our state. And we will take the time to get it right."
2) Response from the State Board of Education:
On February 8, 2008
Jennifer Sheets, President of the State Board of Education, issued a
letter to Governor Strickland responding to a proposal in the
Governor's State of the State Address to create a Director of
Education and turn the State Board and Superintendent of Public
Instruction into advisors. In the letter President Sheets outlines
the following reasons for supporting the current structure of the
State Board of Education and Superintendency, and why changing the
structure would limit participation by the public in education
decisions:
-The people of Ohio included in the Ohio Constitution an independent
structure for State Board of Education and Superintendency to
insulate decisions regarding education from politics;
-The current structure of the State Board ensures that the
geographic, rural, and urban diversity of the state are represented
through eleven Board members who are directly elected by voters, and
eight members who are appointed by the Governor;
-Decisions regarding education are debated and made at public
meetings ensuring transparency;
-The structure of the Board ensures that changes in the political
makeup of the Ohio General Assembly or Governor's Office do not
disrupt the operations and programs that the State Board oversees; and
-The State Board of Education is ready to work in partnership with
the Governor's Office to "bring new ideas to the table", but cannot
support "...any proposal that would reduce the importance of the
board and state superintendent and thus take the "public" out of
public education."
3) 127th General Assembly:
The Ohio House and Senate are not
holding sessions this week. Some Ohio House and Senate Committees
will be meeting, but not the education committees.
*The Ohio Senate Finance and Financial Institutions Committee,
chaired by Senator Carey, will meet on Tuesday, February 12, 2008 at
11:00 AM in the Senate Finance Hearing Room. The Committee will hear
testimony on SB273 (Niehaus) Classroom Facilities Assistance, which
calculates an alternate equity list for fiscal year 2008 to determine
school district eligibility for assistance under the Classroom
Facilities Assistance Program, and their local shares in fiscal year
2009.
*The STEM Subcommittee of the Partnership for Continued Learning will
meet on February 13, 2008 at 1:00 PM at the Ohio Board of Regents, 30
E. Broad St., 36th Floor. At this meeting the Subcommittee will
select the recipients of STEM school and STEM program of excellence
grants, which will be available starting July 2008. To see an agenda
of this meeting please visit http://www.pcl.ohio.gov/jcore/pcl/HomeContent.jsp?node=D676EB47-8397-4427-B393-73645554EC80.
4) President Makes Last Budget Request:
President Bush submitted
his 2009 budget to Congress on February 4, 2008. The $3.1 trillion
budget request includes cuts in 151 government programs, including
those in education, health care, the environment, the arts, and
programs to help low income earners. It also extends the tax cuts of
2001 and 2003, and would increase the total federal deficit to $547
billion in FY 08-13, according to the Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities. (http://www.cbpp.org/2-4-08bud2.htm)
The budget for the U.S. Department of Education would total $59.2
billion, unchanged from FY08. A slight increase of 2.9 percent is
proposed for Title 1 ($14.3 billion), which includes funds to support
the No Child Left Behind Act. The budget also expands funding for
school choice ($300 million); Reading First (restored to $1 billion);
the Teacher Incentive Fund ($200 million increase); America's
Competitiveness Initiative ($175 million, including an increase for
Advanced Placement and IB); Individuals with Disabilities Act ($11.3
billion including an increase of $377 million); and almost $19
billion for the Pell Grant Program for low-income college students.
The proposed budget eliminates 47 programs, saving $3.3 billion,
including Career and Technical Education Grants to states ($1.6
billion); Even Start ($66.5 million); Educational Technology State
Grants ($267.5 million); Arts in Education ($37.5 million), and
reduces spending for other programs, such as Safe and Drug Free
Schools and 21st Century Learning Opportunities.
The President's budget proposal is unlikely to be approved as
introduced. The federal budget submitted by the executive provides
an outline of expenditures, but Congress distributes funds to
government agencies and departments through several appropriations
bills. Congress is likely to approve a continuing resolution to fund
federal programs past the end of the fiscal year on September 30,
2008 until a new president takes office in 2009.
5) State Board of Education to Meet:
The State Board of Education
(SBE), Jennifer Sheets president, will meet on February 10-12, 2008
in Columbus, Ohio.
The State Board of Education's Quality Middle and High Schools and
School Funding subcommittees met on February 10, 2008 at the Embassy
Suites Hotel in Columbus.
The State Board of Education will hold its meetings on February
11-12, 2008 at the Ohio School for the Deaf, 500 Morse Road,
Columbus, OH. On February 11, 2008 the Achievement Committee,
Michael Cochran and Ann Womer Benjamin co-chairs, and Capacity
Committee, Rob Hovis and Jane Sonenshein co-chairs, will meet at 8:30
AM.
The Capacity Committee will discuss Ohio Administrative Code Rule
3301-26-01, Educator Examinations; Rule 3301-71-01 Disadvantaged
Pupil Impact Aid; approve an intent to amend Rule 3301-8-01 Payment
of Debt Service Charges; discuss legislative recommendations for
Performance Standards for Dropout Recovery Schools; discuss the Safe
Schools Summit recommendations; and discuss the Educator Code of
Conduct draft.
The Achievement Committee will approve an intent to amend Ohio
Administrative Code Rule 3301-61-17 Emergency Service
Telecommunicator Training; approve a resolution to refile revised
Chapter 3301-51 regarding Operating Standards for Children with
Disabilities; and approve a resolution of intent to adopt the Perkins
IV Five-Year Plan.
The Legislative Report will be presented at 10:45 AM by Board members
John Bender and Carl Wick. At 11:30 AM the full Board will discuss
legislative recommendations for performance standards for Dropout
Recovery Schools.
After lunch at 1:15 PM the Achievement Committee will present
information about the Perkins IV Five Year Plan. At 2:15 PM the
Board will discuss the draft Educator Code of Conduct, and then
review the agenda for the business meeting on Tuesday, hear reports
from subcommittees, and hear an update on financial literacy.
Deborah Wickerham, the 2008 Ohio Teacher of the Year, will be
recognized by the Board at 3:45 PM
At 4:00 PM the Board will hold a Chapter 119 Hearing on the following rules:
-Amend Ohio Administrative Code Rule (OAC) 3301-51-15 - Gifted Services
-Amend OAC Rules 3301-35-05 and 06 Operating Standards
-Amend OAC Rule 3301-44-09 Postsedondary Enrollment Options
-Amend OAC Rule 3301-52-01, Screening and Assessment
-Rescind Rules 3301-69-11 and 12, Head Start, Head Start Plus.
The Board will adjourn at 5:15 PM. The State Board of Education's
Subcommittee for Education in the New Global Economy (EDGE) will meet
from 5:30 - 7:00 PM.
On February 12, 2008 the State Board of Education's meeting will
begin at 8:15 AM with a policy discussion about targeted efforts to
improve achievement in Ohio's urban districts. At 9:45 PM Board
members will discuss the alignment of the work of various
subcommittees, and at 10:15 AM the Achievement Committee working
group and Capacity Committee working group will meet to discuss
transforming Ohio's system of education.
The Board will convene its business meeting at 11:15 AM and
immediately proceed into executive session. Following lunch at 1:30
PM the Board will continue its business meeting starting with the
report of the Superintendent of Public Instruction and public
participation on agenda items. The Board will take action on 12
school personnel items and the resolutions included below. The Board
will then accept public participation on non-agenda items and
adjourn. The next State Board of Education meeting is March 10-11,
2008.
Agenda of the State Board of Education for February 12, 2008:
-Approve a Resolution of Intent to amend OAC Rule 3301-8-01 Payment
of Debt Service Charges
-Approve a Resolution of Intent to amend OAC Rule 3301-61-17
Emergency Service Telecommunicator Training
-Approve a Resolution of Intent to amend OAC Rule 3301-83-04, 06,
-09, -10, and 16 Pupil Transportation Operation and Safety
-Approve a Resolution of Intent to adopt the Ohio Five Year Plan for
the administration of Career Technical Education effective July 1,
2008 through June 30, 2013.
-Approve a resolution to accept the recommendation of the hearing
officer and deny the transfer of school district territory from the
Franklin City School District, Warren County, to the Middletown City
School District, Butler County.
-Approve a Resolution to amend OAC Rule 3301-23-44 Temporary Licenses
-Approve a Resolution to rescind and adopt new OAC Rule 3301-24-09
Performance Based Licensure for Administrators
-Approve a Resolution to amend OAC Rules 3310-48-01-02 regarding open
enrollment programs
-Approve a Resolution to refile proposed new OAC Rules 3301-51-01,
09, and 11 regarding Operating Standards for Children with
Disabilities
-Approve a Resolution regarding the 2008 Ohio Teacher of the Year
-Approve a Resolution to adopt a revised fee structure for all
educator licenses, certificates, and permits issued by the ODE
6) Discussion with Thomas Friedman and Daniel Pink:
The February
2008 issue of The School Administrator includes a discussion between
Thomas Friedman, author of "The World is Flat" and Daniel Pink,
author of "The Whole New Mind". The authors discuss education and
what students need to do to prepare themselves for living and working
in a competitive and interconnected world.
Referring to the latest edition of his book, Thomas Friedman said, "In the latest edition, I added a whole section on why liberal arts
are more important than ever. It's not that I don't think math and
science are important. They still are.. but more than ever our
secret sauce comes from our ability to integrate arts, science, music
and literature with the hard sciences. That's what produces an iPod
revolution or a Google."
Daniel Pink then added, "It's the combination of the left brain and
the right brain. Left-brain thinking --rule-based, linear, SAT-style
thinking -- used to be enough. Now right-brain thinking --artistry,
empathy, narrative, synthesis -- is the big differentiator."
Friedman's learning foundation is CQ + PQ > IQ, which stands for
curiosity quotient plus passion quotient is more important than
intelligence quotient. Both authors believe that to produce
innovative students the education system needs to have more team
teaching, integrate the arts into the curriculum, support writing
across the subject areas, and empower students to use their
imagination. According to Friedman, "So the school, the state, the
country that empowers, nurtures, enables imagination among its
students and citizens, that's who's going to be the winner."
The article is available at
http://www.aasa.org/publications/saarticledetail.cfm?ItemNumber=9736&snItemNumber=950&tnItemNumber
7) Interim Report on School Finance Released:
The University of
Washington and the Center on Reinventing Public Education have issued
an interim report written by Paul Hill on the work of the "School
Finance Redesign Project". This project encompasses research, policy
analysis, and public engagement activities that examine how K-12
finance can be redesigned to better support student performance. The
project addresses the basic question, "How can resources help schools
achieve the higher levels of student performance that state and
national education standards now demand?" by researching the
following questions:
Are public funds focused on student learning?
Are there good ideas about how to focus money on instruction?
Are there good ideas about attracting and rewarding quality educators?
Do we know enough now to say exactly how money should be spent?
How can policymakers spend the right among and ensure that funds are
used effectively for student learning?
The project was initiated in 2002 and is supported by the Bill &
Melinda Gates Foundation. It now encompasses more than 30 separate
projects. The interim report provides an overview of the projects
underway, who is doing the research, the research questions and
strategies being used, and some of the preliminary findings. This
report is available at http://www.schoolfinanceredesign.org/pub/pdf/sfrp_interim_07_web.pdf